Former Manchester United defender Patrice Evra has opened up on why he considers his former teammate Cristiano Ronaldo ahead of Lionel Messi in the long-running debate over the greatest player of their generation.

The Ronaldo-Messi rivalry has dominated world football for nearly two decades, with both players achieving extraordinary success at club and international levels. While opinions remain divided among fans and analysts, Evra insists his preference is shaped by what he witnessed firsthand during his time at Manchester United.

Speaking via The Telegraph, Evra emphasised that Ronaldo’s relentless work ethic is what truly separates him from others.

“Anyone might have talent, but do you put in the effort? Messi fans don’t like me when I say Cristiano Ronaldo is the best of his generation… However, it’s his hard work that stands out,” he said.

Evra joined Manchester United in 2006, three years after Ronaldo’s arrival, and watched the Portuguese forward develop into one of the world’s elite players. Having also faced Messi multiple times during his career, the Frenchman believes both players followed different paths — with Messi blessed with natural talent, while Ronaldo built his greatness through intense dedication and training.

Opinion: Talent vs Hard Work — A Debate That May Never End

Evra’s comments reflect a broader philosophical question in sports: is greatness defined more by natural ability or by effort? Ronaldo’s story is often celebrated as proof that discipline, ambition, and relentless improvement can elevate a player to historic levels. Messi, on the other hand, represents the beauty of innate genius — a reminder that some abilities simply cannot be taught.

What makes the debate fascinating is that both players reached similar heights through different routes. One inspires through determination, the other through artistry. Comparing them may even miss the bigger point — football has been privileged to witness two generational icons at the same time.

Ultimately, preferences often come down to personal values. Those who admire work ethic and physical excellence lean toward Ronaldo, while those who appreciate creativity and natural flair gravitate toward Messi. Either way, their rivalry has enriched football history, giving fans unforgettable moments that will be discussed for decades.