Semenyo Picks Messi Over Ronaldo in Greatest Player Debate

Bournemouth forward Antoine Semenyo has weighed in on football’s long-running greatest-of-all-time debate, naming Inter Miami captain Lionel Messi as the better player ahead of Al-Nassr star Cristiano Ronaldo.

Speaking during a segment on the AwayDays YouTube channel, the 25-year-old was asked to choose between the two global icons. His response was clear and decisive.

“Messi, 100%,” Semenyo said. “I’m not downplaying what Ronaldo has done. What he has done is unbelievable. And what they are both doing is great. But personally, I’m a Messi fan.”

Messi and Ronaldo are widely regarded as two of the greatest players the sport has ever produced. Both are now in the twilight of their illustrious careers and are expected to feature in what could be their final FIFA World Cup tournament next year, adding further emotion to an already legendary rivalry.

Opinion: Preference, Not Disrespect

Semenyo’s comments reflect a sentiment shared by many players and fans: choosing Messi over Ronaldo is often about style and connection rather than achievement. While Ronaldo’s physical dominance, longevity, and goal-scoring records are extraordinary, Messi’s creativity, vision, and effortless brilliance continue to win hearts across generations.

What makes this debate enduring is that there is no wrong answer. Both players have redefined excellence in different ways, pushing each other to heights few thought possible. As their careers edge closer to the final chapter, opinions like Semenyo’s serve as reminders of the personal impact these legends have had on players who grew up watching them.

In the end, whether it’s Messi’s magic or Ronaldo’s relentless drive, football has been richer for having both—and fans may soon realise just how rare this era truly was.